Newer Roof!! Step into a piece of history with this 1901 Queen Anne Victorian beauty. With some thoughtful updates and bright teal or even pink exterior paint this home could be a “KeyWest Beauty!” In the hub of golf cart / porch district. Spanning nearly 4,000 square feet, this five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath residence is significantly larger than comparable historic homes in the area. Originally built as a grand residence and later serving as a charming bed and breakfast, the home features a gorgeous carved wood front door, original hardwood floors on the first and second levels, and charming angled ceilings on the third floor.
The main level greets you with refreshing light blue walls in the living and dining areas, complemented by decorative fireplaces. The updated kitchen boasts creamy earth-tone finishes, a wooden range hood, a butler’s pantry, a walk-in pantry, and a dedicated storage room. Outside, you can enjoy breezy evenings on the beautiful front porch with original Victorian woodwork or relax on the second-story deck. Located in the heart of Sanford’s Residential Historic District, this fully fenced, zero-lot-line property offers the quintessential Sanford lifestyle. It is a golf-cart-friendly community a close distance to three parks, the Lake Monroe Riverwalk, local craft breweries, and the vibrant Saturday Farmers Market. From the boutiques and the Wayne Densch Performing Arts Center to the lively ‘Alive After 5’ street parties, this home provides a front-row seat to the best of historic Sanford.
With thoughtful restoration, this historic gem has tremendous potential to shine.
The main level greets you with refreshing light blue walls in the living and dining areas, complemented by decorative fireplaces. The updated kitchen boasts creamy earth-tone finishes, a wooden range hood, a butler’s pantry, a walk-in pantry, and a dedicated storage room. Outside, you can enjoy breezy evenings on the beautiful front porch with original Victorian woodwork or relax on the second-story deck. Located in the heart of Sanford’s Residential Historic District, this fully fenced, zero-lot-line property offers the quintessential Sanford lifestyle. It is a golf-cart-friendly community a close distance to three parks, the Lake Monroe Riverwalk, local craft breweries, and the vibrant Saturday Farmers Market. From the boutiques and the Wayne Densch Performing Arts Center to the lively ‘Alive After 5’ street parties, this home provides a front-row seat to the best of historic Sanford.
With thoughtful restoration, this historic gem has tremendous potential to shine.
Property Details
Price:
$499,999
MLS #:
O6393728
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Baths:
4.5
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
SANFORD TOWN OF
Neighborhood:
32771sanfordlakeforest
Listed Date:
Mar 25, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
3,717
Total Sq Ft:
3,717
Lot Size:
2,701 sqft / 0.06 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1901
See this Listing
Schools
Elementary School:
Hamilton Elementary
Middle School:
Markham Woods Middle
High School:
Seminole High
Interior
Appliances
Dishwasher, Disposal, Freezer, Microwave
Bathrooms
4 Full Bathrooms, 1 Half Bathroom
Cooling
Central Air, Mini-Split Unit(s), Wall/Window Unit(s)
Flooring
Carpet, Hardwood
Heating
Electric, Wall Units / Window Unit
Interior Features
Crown Molding, High Ceilings
Laundry Features
Inside, Laundry Room
Levels
Three Or More
Exterior
Architectural Style
Victorian
Construction Materials
Wood Siding
Direction Faces
North
Exterior Features
Balcony, Sidewalk
Fencing
Fenced
Lot Features
Historic District, City Lot, Sidewalk
Patio And Porch Features
Covered, Deck, Front Porch
Roof
Shingle
Window Features
Wood Frames
Financial
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$1,186
Map
Community
- Address209 E 5TH STREET SANFORD FL
- SubdivisionSANFORD TOWN OF
- CitySANFORD
- CountySeminole
- Zip Code32771
Subdivisions in SANFORD
- 1700 FIRST STREET
- 260 POWER CT 100-110
- 260 POWER CT 110
- 300 BETWEEN US 1 AND RIVER
- A F G VEGETABLE TR
- ACADEMY MANOR UNIT 01
- ACADEMY MANOR UNIT 02
- ACREAGE & UNREC
- AERO 8 INDUST PARK A CONDO
- AMBERLEE TOWNHOMES
- AMBERLEE TWNHMS
- ARBOR LAKES A CONDO
- ASTOR GRANDE AT LAKE FOREST
- AUTUMN CHASE
- BAKERS CROSSING PH 1
- BAKERS CROSSING PH 2
- BAKERS CROSSING PH I
- BARTRAMS LANDING AT ST JOHNS
- BEL-AIR SANFORD
- BELAIR PLACE
- BELLA FORESTA
- BERINGTON CLUB PH 1
- BERINGTON CLUB PH 2
- BOOKERTOWN
- BOYKIN PLACE
- BRADBURY
- BRADBURY ESTATES
- BROWNS SUB OF BECK HAMMOCK
- BRYNHAVEN 1ST REP
- BRYNWOOD
- BUCKINGHAM ESTATES
- BUCKINGHAM ESTS
- BUENA VISTA ESTATES
- BUNGALOW CITY
- CADENCE PARK
- CANAAN
- CARRIAGE COVE
- CARRIAGE HOMES AT DUNWOODY COMMONS A CONDO
- CASTILLE TWNHMS CONDO
- CELERY ESTATES NORTH
- CELERY KEY
- CELERY LAKES PH 1
- CELERY LAKES PH 2
- CELERY OAKS SUB
- CELERY OAKS SUBDIVISION
- CHAPPELLS SUB A D
- CHAPPELLS SUBD A D
- CITY OF SANFORD
- CONCORDE
- CONCORDE PH 2
- COUNTRY CLUB MANOR UNIT 3
- COUNTRY CLUB PARK
- COUNTRY CLUB PARK PH 2
- COUNTRY CLUB PARK PH 3
- COUNTRY CLUN MANOR UNIT 1
- DE FORESTS ADD
- DIXIE TERRACE
- DREAMWOLD
- DREAMWOLD 3RD SEC
- DREAMWORLD 3RD SECTION
- DRUID PARK AMD
- DUNWOODY COMMONS PH 1
- DUNWOODY COMMONS PH 2
- DUNWOODY PLAZA
- EASTGROVE
- EASTGROVE PH 2
- ELNORA SQUARE AMD
- EMERALD POINTE
- EMERALD POINTE AT BERYL LANDING
- ENCLAVE AT SILVER LAKE
- ESTATES AT LAKE JESUP
- ESTATES AT RIVERCREST
- ESTATES AT WEKIVA PARK
- EUREKA HAMMOCK
- FAIRLANE ESTATES
- FAIRLANE ESTATES SEC 1 REP
- FLA LAND & COLONIZATION COS ADD TO SOUTH SANFORD
- FLAGSHIP PARK A CONDO
- FLAGSHIP PARK A CONDOMINIUM
- FLORA HEIGHTS
- FOREST GLEN SUB
- FORT MELLON 2ND SEC
- FRANKLIN TERRACE
- FT MELLON
- FULTON PARK
- GEORGIA ACRES
- GOLDSBORO COMMUNITY
- GRACELINE COURT
- GREENBRIAR 3RD SEC OF LOCH ARBOR
- GREYSTONE PH 1
- GREYSTONE PH 2
- GREYSTONE PHASE 2
- GROVEVIEW VILLAGE 1ST ADD REP
- HAMILTON PLACE
- HAZEL GLEN
- HIDDEN LAKE PH 2 UNIT 2
- HIDDEN LAKE PH 2 UNIT 4
- HIDDEN LAKE PH 2 UNIT 5
- HIDDEN LAKE PH 3 UNIT 2
- HIDDEN LAKE PH 3 UNIT 6
- HIDDEN LAKE UNIT 1-C
- HIDDEN LAKE VILLAS PH 3
- HIGHLAND PARK
- HIGHLAND PARK REP OF LT A
- HIGHLAND PARK REP OF POR OF BLK 1
- HOLDEN REAL ESTATE COMPANYS ADD
- IDYLLWILDE OF LOCH ARBOR REP
- INDIAN MOUND VILLAGE
- INDIAN MOUND VILLAGE-ST. JOHNS RIVER
- KAYS LANDING PH 2
- KAYWOOD REP
- KENSINGTON RESERVE
- KENSINGTON RESERVE PH II
- KENSINGTON RESERVE PH III
- KERSEYS ADD TO MIDWAY
- LAKE FOREST SEC 1
- LAKE FOREST SEC 14
- LAKE FOREST SEC 16
- LAKE FOREST SEC 4A
- LAKE FOREST SEC 7A
- LAKE FOREST SEC TWO A
- LAKE FOREST VILLAGE SHOPPES
- LAKE FOREST-SECTION THREE B PH 3
- LAKE FOREST-SECTION THREE B PH 4
- LAKE JESUP WOODS
- LAKE MARKHAM ESTATES
- LAKE MARKHAM PRESERVE
- LAKE SYLVAN ESTATES
- LAKE VIEW PARK
- LANDINGS AT RIVERBEND
- LANDINGS AT RIVERBEND TOWNHOMES
- LEAVITTS SUB W F
- LEXINGTON PARK
- LINCOLN HEIGHTS SEC 1
- LINCOLN HEIGHTS SEC 2
- LOCH ARBOR CRYSTAL LAKES CLUB SEC
- LOCKHARTS SUB
- LORDLAND
- LORDS 1ST ADD TO CITRUS
- LOT 13 GREYSTONE PHASE 2 PB 68 PGS 81 – 87
- MAGNOLIA CLUB
- MAGNOLIA PARK
- MARKHAM ESTATES SUB
- MARKHAM FOREST
- MARKHAM PARK HEIGHTS
- MARKHAM WOODS
- MARVANIA 1ST SEC
- MATERA
- MAYFAIR
- MAYFAIR CLUB
- MAYFAIR CLUB PH 1
- MAYFAIR CLUB PH 2
- MAYFAIR MEADOWS
- MAYFAIR OAKS
- MECCA HAMMOCK
- MEISCHS SUB
- MIDDLETON OAKS
- MIDWAY
- MIDWAY COMMERCE CENTER
- MIDWAY COMMERCE CENTER 1ST ADD
- MIDWAY PACKARDS 1ST ADD TO MIDWAY
- MIDWAY PARK
- MONROE MEADOWS
- MONTEREY OAKS
- MONTEREY OAKS PH 1, A REP
- MONTEREY OAKS PH 2 REP
- MUNSONS SUB W B
- NEW UPSALA
- NORTH SEMINOLE CONDO
- NORTHLAKE VILLAGE CONDO 5
- NORTHLAKE VILLAGE CONDO 6
- NORTHLAKE VILLAGE CONDO 7
- NORTHLAKE VILLAGE CONDO 8
- NORTHSTAR BUS PARK PH 2
- ORANGE PARK SANFORD
- PACKARDS 1ST ADD TO MIDWAY
- PALM HAMMOCK
- PALM PLACE
- PALM POINT
- PALM TERRACE
- PARKVIEW PLACE
- PARTINS SUB OF LT 27
- PEARL LAKE ESTATES
- PHILLIPS TERRACE
- PINE CREST
- PINE HGTS
- PINE LEVEL
- PINE RIDGE CLUB II
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 10 BLDG 12
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 12 BLDG 15
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 3 A CONDO BLDG 9
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 5
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 6
- PINE RIDGE CLUB VILLAGE 1 PH 6 BLDG 13
- PINEHURST
- PINEHURST 1ST ADD
- PLACID LAKE TWNHMS
- PLACID WOODS PH 2
- PLACID WOODS PH 3
- PRESERVE AT ASTOR FARMS
- PRESERVE AT ASTOR FARMS PH 1
- PRESERVE AT ASTOR FARMS PH 2
- PRESERVE AT ASTOR FARMS PH 3
- PRESERVE AT DEER LAKES
- PRESERVE AT EAGLE LAKE
- PRESERVE AT LAKE MONROE
- PRINCETON PLACE
- RAVENNA PARK 2ND SEC OF LOCH ARBOR
- REAGAN POINTE
- REGENCY OAKS UNIT ONE
- REGENCY OAKS UNIT TWO
- RESERVE AT LOCH LAKE
- RETREAT AT TWIN LAKES REP
- RETREAT AT WEKIVA – PH 2
- REVISED OF HIDDEN LAKE UNIT 1-A
- RIVER CREST PH 1
- RIVER RUN PRESERVE
- RIVERBEND
- RIVERBEND AT CAMERON HEIGHTS
- RIVERBEND AT CAMERON HEIGHTS PH 2
- RIVERBEND AT CAMERON HEIGHTS PH 3
- RIVERBEND AT CAMERON HEIGHTS PH 4
- RIVERSIDE OAKS
- RIVERSIDE OAKS PH 1
- RIVERSIDE OAKS PH 2
- RIVERSIDE OAKS PH 3
- RIVERSIDE OAKS PH 4
- RIVERVIEW TOWNHOMES
- RIVERVIEW TWNHMS PH II
- ROBINSONS SURVEY
- ROBINSONS SURVEY OF AN ADD TO SANFORD
- ROSALIND HEIGHTS
- ROSE COURT
- ROSE COURT REPLAT
- ROSECREST
- ROSELAND PARK
- ROSS LAKE SHORES
- RUSSELLS ADD FORT REED
- SAN LANTA
- SAN LANTA 2ND SEC
- SAN LANTA 3RD SEC
- SAN SEM KNOLLS
- SANDLEWOOD CONDO
- SANFORD
- SANFORD CELERY DELTA
- SANFORD FARMS
- SANFORD HEIGHTS
- SANFORD PLACE
- SANFORD PLAZA CONDO
- SANFORD PLAZA CONDOMINIUM
- SANFORD TERRACE
- SANFORD TOWN OF
- SAVANNAH PARK
- SEMINOLE ESTATES
- SEMINOLE ESTATES UNIT 2
- SEMINOLE PARK
- SHADOW LAKE WOODS
- SHEPHERDS ADD
- SILVERLEAF
- SIPES FEHR
- SKYLAR CREST
- SOUTH PINECREST 1ST ADD
- SOUTH PINECREST 2ND ADD
- SOUTH PINECREST 3RD ADD
- SOUTH SANFORD
- SOUTH SANFORD HEIGHTS ADD
- ST JOHNS RIVER ESTATES
- ST JOSEPHS
- STENDIFORDS ADD
- STERLING MEADOWS
- STERLING WOODS
- STEVENS ADD TO MIDWAY
- SUNLAND ESTATES
- SUNLAND ESTATES 1ST ADD
- SUNLAND ESTATES AMD
- SYLVA GLADE
- SYLVAN ESTATES
- SYLVAN LAKE RESERVE / THE GLADES ON SYLVAN LAKE
- SYLVAN LAKE TOWN OF
- SYLVAN TRAILS
- TALL TREES
- TEE N GREEN ESTATES
- TERRACE THE
- TERRACINA AT LAKE FOREST
- TERRACINA AT LAKE FOREST FIFTH AMD
- TERRACINA AT LAKE FOREST FOURTH AMD
- TERRACINA AT LAKE FOREST SECOND AMD
- TERRACINA AT LAKE FOREST THIRD AMD
- THE ARBORS AT HIDDEN LAKE SEC 1
- THE ARBORS AT HIDDEN LAKE SEC 1 REP
- THE ARBORS AT HIDDEN LAKE SEC 2
- THE FOUNTAINS MARKET PLACE A CONDO
- THE GLADES ON SYLVAN LAKE
- THE GLADES ON SYLVAN LAKE PH 2
- THORNBROOKE
- THORNBROOKE PH 1
- THORNBROOKE PH 2
- THORNBROOKE PH 5
- TOWNHOMES AT RIVERS EDGE
- TOWNS AT LAKE MONROE COMMONS
- TOWNS AT RIVERWALK
- TOWNS AT WHITE CEDAR
- TRADITIONS AT WHITE CEDAR
- TROPIC PARK
- TUSCA PLACE NORTH
- TUSCA PLACE SOUTH
- TWENTY WEST
- UPSALA BUS PARK
- VIA FORESTA
- VILLAS DU SOLEIL
- WALDEN COVE
- WASHINGTON OAKS SEC 1
- WASHINGTON OAKS SEC 2
- WEKIVA CAMP SITES REP
- WEKIVA CAMP SITES REPLAT
- WEST SANFORD REALTY CO SUBD
- WHITE CEDAR TOWN HOME
- WINDSOR LAKE TOWNHOMES
- WINDSOR LAKE TWNHMS EAST
- WINDSOR SQUARE
- WM CLARKS SUB
- WOODBINE
- WOODMERE PARK 2ND REP
- WOODRUFFS SUB FRANK L
- WYNDHAM PRESERVE
- WYNNEWOOD
- YANKEE LAKE SUB
- YANKEE LAKE SUBD
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in SANFORD as of Jul 30, 2026
403
Single Family Listed
111
Avg DOM
235
Avg $ / SqFt
$512,220
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the SANFORD TOWN OF subdivision, 209 E 5TH STREET SANFORD FL is a Single Family for sale in SANFORD, FL, 32771. It is listed for $499,999 and features 5 beds, 5 baths, and has approximately 3,717 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1901. The current price per square foot is $135. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in SANFORD is $235. The average listing price for Single Family in SANFORD is $512,220. To schedule a showing of MLS#o6393728 at 209 E 5TH STREET in SANFORD, FL, contact your CENTURY 21 Carioti agent at 2392986550.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of PETRA WORLDWIDE. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CENTURY 21 Carioti include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor CENTURY 21 Carioti shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 209 E 5TH STREET
SANFORD, FL
