5793 OLD RANCH ROAD SARASOTA FL 34241 MLS #A4620072 | Gary Kusher | Florida Real Estate

Myakka Valley Ranches, “Sarasota County’s last frontier:” Great opportunity to acquire a beautiful, very
private, 5-acre lot with 2 big homes (each with an attached air-conditioned garage), a spectacular pool,
and a big air-conditioned outbuilding for a remarkably low price.
The 3,515 SF 2-story home in the front has a ground floor master suite with skylights, and two bedrooms
upstairs, both with en suite bathrooms. The large kitchen was fully renovated in 2011, with quartz
countertops, center island and seating peninsula; walk-in party. Large living room with fireplace, and
dining room, fully renovated in 2023.

The home has four baths, an upstairs balcony/deck with beautiful views of the pond, and several
screened porches. The downstairs master is currently used as a work area. This could also serve as a
rental since it has a utility kitchen and a bathroom. In front of the home is a 1,092 sf air-conditioned
building, which was once a 3-car garage (the overhead doors are still in place). It features a kitchenette
and a half bath. This would be a great space for a studio, caretaker, home-schooling office, you name it.
On the left side of the house is an attached carport, which is connected to an air-conditioned 702 sf 2-
car garage. The 2,848 sf home in the back of the property features a big (1,800 sf) pool deck with a
spectacular ray-shaped heated pool. In its center is a built-in hot tub with ray-shaped grotto and
waterfall. A huge industrial fan is one of the first things you notice upon entering the light and bright 20
x 40 studio/office on the south side of the house. A breezeway connects the house to an 1,131 sf 3-car
air-conditioned garage. The 5+ acre lot is spectacular: a big pond in the center separates the two homes,
while many big live oak trees, all kinds of palm trees, and bamboo clusters give it a distinctly tropical,
“Florida” vibe. The reason that this property is priced so competitively (7,455 SF airconditioned living
space, at $228/SF, compared to a median sale price of $401/sf in the community since 1/7/23) has to
do with the unfortunate effect of hurricane Ian, an exceptionally destructive storm: the back house
flooded in 9/23, and will need a major make-over. A beginning has been made: floors, doors, closets,
bathroom fixtures, appliances, kitchen cabinets, and all the affected sections of drywall have been
removed, and mold remediation has taken place. The A/C is running, and the pool is clean. It was
planned as a 3/2 house, but it would be rather easy to change this configuration. Because the front
house is higher (flood zone x), it only had minor water intrusion, which has been professionally restored.
Myakka Valley Ranches is one of the most beautiful equestrian communities in Sarasota. The ca. 280
homes are all situated on at least 5 acres. Winding roads and nature trails provide its residents with the
opportunity to walk, ride their bicycle or horse in a stunningly beautiful environment. There is even a
community park (close to the listing), where one can launch a kayak, and paddle to the Upper Lake of
Myakka River State Park, Florida’s biggest state park at 37,000 acres. Downtown Sarasota, with its many
cultural amenities, is only 40 minutes away, as are the award-winning beaches of Siesta Key. Great
restaurants, shops, and good public and private schools are all within 30 minutes from “the Valley,” as
the locals call their slice of paradise.